News

UK tribunal rejects secrecy over Apple capability notice

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the UK government’s attempt to conceal the existence of a technical capability notice issued to Apple, but did not rule on its legality or order its contents disclosed.

D
Nov 19, 2026 · 2 min read

The UK’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal has rejected the government’s attempt to keep secret the existence of a technical capability notice issued to Apple. In its open judgment, the tribunal stated as a fact that the Home Secretary had given Apple a notice and rejected the contention that confirming that fact would damage national security.

As a result, the government can no longer maintain a neither-confirm-nor-deny position on whether this notice exists. Much, but not all, of Apple’s substantive challenge and a separate claim by Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner can also be heard openly.

That greater transparency has clear limits. The ruling does not reveal the notice’s precise requirements, nor does it decide whether the notice or the statutory regime behind it is lawful, necessary or proportionate.

The government had argued that official confirmation or denial would damage national security and weaken its neither-confirm-nor-deny policy in future cases. The tribunal found that the position had not been applied consistently. It inferred that newspaper briefings about the notice had been authorised and said the government’s risk assessment did not adequately address those departures.

The judges distinguished between acknowledging the notice and disclosing its details. Some material may remain secret where national security or the wider public interest separately justifies secrecy. The tribunal said the disclosure boundary should be settled after evidence and written arguments establish what information matters to the substantive cases.

A technical capability notice is a mechanism under section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 through which the Home Secretary can direct a relevant operator to maintain specified technical capabilities. The published case record identifies the ruling as [2026] UKIPTrib 9.

Apple’s five unresolved grounds include whether the law permits requirements involving communications outside the UK, how the regime applies to security and privacy services, whether consultation was adequate, whether the notice is proportionate under the European Convention on Human Rights, and whether Apple was treated differently from other technology companies. None was resolved by this case-management judgment.

Apple brought an initial claim in early 2025. It was later dismissed after a change in circumstances, and the company began a second claim in July 2026.

The judgment says the parties regarded a December 2026 merits hearing as impractical and expected to agree directions toward a substantive hearing in the first half of 2027. It does not set an exact hearing date.

More news